Bathroom Fixtures Alternatives Worth Comparing: Simple Project “Botanic Noir” configurations explained (and how they stack up vs comfort‑height options)

What these 15 Botanic Noir SKUs really are

Each SKU is a configuration of Simple Project’s Botanic Noir bathroom idea: a coordinated set centered on an extra‑tall two‑piece toilet, a 60 in. framed/sliding glass shower door, and a rattan‑front vanity with optional LED medicine cabinet. The functional differences that affect fit and everyday use are the toilet’s bowl shape and flush system, seat height, the shower door finish, and whether you add the 60x36 in. pan.

Core specs from Simple Project’s listings: the extra‑tall dual‑flush elongated option lists a 21.8 in. seat height and 0.8/1.28 gpf; the single‑flush elongated option lists a 20.5 in. seat height at 1.28 gpf; the round‑bowl option is 21.8 in. seat height at 1.28 gpf. All note a standard 12 in. rough‑in. The door is listed at about 60 in. W x 75 in. H, and some SKUs bundle a matching 60x36 in. white pan.

How the toilet options differ (the choice that matters most)

Seat height and flush type drive most of the real‑world difference, followed by bowl shape for space and comfort:

• 21.8 in. seat height, elongated, dual‑flush 0.8/1.28 gpf: reduces knee/hip bend for tall users and those who prefer an extra‑tall seat. Use the light flush consistently to realize water savings. Verify WaterSense labeling on the exact model if you need rebates.
• 20.5 in. seat height, elongated, single‑flush 1.28 gpf: simpler operation, slightly lower seat that may feel more natural to average‑height users.
• 21.8 in. seat height, round‑bowl, single‑flush 1.28 gpf: saves a bit of front‑to‑back length for tight rooms or close door swings.
• ADA note: ADA seat height is 17–19 in. to the top of the seat; the 21.8 in. options exceed ADA maximum height and are not ADA‑height for code purposes.

Choosing hardware finishes for the shower door

Three finishes coordinate the look. Care needs differ slightly:

• Matte Black: dramatic contrast; shows mineral spots/fingerprints more readily; stick to non‑abrasive cleaners and wipe/squeegee glass after use.
• Brushed Nickel: tends to hide fingerprints and water spots better; widely used for a low‑maintenance look.
• Brushed Gold: durable PVD‑style finishes from major brands are known for longevity; pair with warm‑tone fixtures and lights.

Door‑only vs door + 60x36 in. white pan

Some SKUs add a 60x36 in. white shower pan to the 60 in. sliding door. If you’re replacing only the door, confirm your existing pan’s threshold and opening match the door’s requirements; if you’re doing a full alcove refresh, the pan bundle simplifies compatibility.

Model‑by‑model: match a SKU to your needs

Use these groupings to jump straight to the configuration that fits your space, finish plan, and seat‑height preference.

• Want the tallest seat and dual‑flush elongated bowl (21.8 in.)? Pick a finish you’ll maintain: Botanic Noir — White Elongated Dual‑Flush + Matte Black hardware, Botanic Noir — White Elongated Dual‑Flush + Brushed Gold hardware, Botanic Noir — White Elongated Dual‑Flush + Brushed Nickel hardware, or bundle the compatible base with Botanic Noir — White Elongated Dual‑Flush + Brushed Nickel hardware, 60x36 in. white pan.
• Prefer simpler single‑flush elongated at a slightly lower 20.5 in. seat height? Choose the style that coordinates with your metals: Botanic Noir — Black Elongated Single‑Flush, Botanic Noir — Black Elongated Single‑Flush + Matte Black hardware, Botanic Noir — Black Elongated Single‑Flush + Brushed Gold hardware, Botanic Noir — Black Elongated Single‑Flush + Brushed Nickel hardware, or go turnkey with Botanic Noir — Black Elongated Single‑Flush + Brushed Nickel hardware, 60x36 in. white pan.
• Tight room and door clearance concerns? The space‑saving round bowl (21.8 in. seat) helps: Botanic Noir — White Round‑Bowl Single‑Flush, Botanic Noir — White Round‑Bowl Single‑Flush + Matte Black hardware, Botanic Noir — White Round‑Bowl Single‑Flush + Brushed Gold hardware, Botanic Noir — White Round‑Bowl Single‑Flush + Brushed Nickel hardware, or include the pan with Botanic Noir — White Round‑Bowl Single‑Flush + Brushed Nickel hardware, 60x36 in. white pan.
• Need a warm‑tone bowl color while keeping the elongated shape? Botanic Noir — Bone Elongated Single‑Flush.

Fit and measurement checklist (avoid the common gotchas)

Before you order, confirm these items to avoid return headaches:

• Rough‑in: Measure from finished wall (not baseboard) to the center of the closet bolts; these models are listed for a standard 12 in. rough‑in.
• Clearances: Elongated bowls provide more seating comfort but extend farther; round bowls help when a swinging door or tight alcove is close.
• Shower opening: The door is listed around 60 in. W x 75 in. H; verify your finished opening width/height and curb/threshold compatibility—especially if you’re reusing an existing pan.
• Pan bundles: The “& 60x36 in. White” SKUs include a pan sized for a 60x36 in. alcove. Confirm drain location and wall construction details match your plan.

What’s in the box (and what isn’t)

Per the extra‑tall dual‑flush listing, the toilet box includes a seat, wax ring, mounting bolts, and an installation guide. For the single‑flush elongated HT‑140‑class listings, a slow‑close seat is specified. Always verify the exact contents on your chosen SKU’s product page before scheduling install.

Care and maintenance tips for finishes and glass

To keep finishes looking new:

• Use non‑abrasive cleaners; avoid ammonia/bleach/solvents on door metal surfaces.
• Squeegee shower glass after each use to reduce spotting and buildup—especially noticeable on Matte Black.
• If minimizing fingerprints and spots is a priority, Brushed Nickel typically hides them better than high‑contrast Matte Black.

Delivery, warranty, and returns (from the listing)

The Botanic Noir listing advertises 4–7 day delivery, a 1‑year warranty, and 30‑day free returns. Check the current policy on the product page at purchase time.

How this compares to familiar comfort‑height options

If you’re also looking at mainstream brands: Kohler and American Standard commonly offer “chair/comfort‑height” toilets around 17–19 in. seat height and also publish lines taller than chair height. Simple Project’s 21.8 in. options sit higher than ADA’s 17–19 in. range; some users prefer the easier stand‑up motion, while others find them too tall for average heights. If you need ADA‑height for a permitted project, choose within 17–19 in.; otherwise pick the height that feels comfortable for daily use.

What buyers liked

Here are recurring positive themes we saw in public discussions; these are shopper impressions, not lab measurements or guarantees:

• Extra‑tall seating made standing up easier for tall users or those with knee/hip discomfort.
• Coordinated Matte Black/Brushed Nickel/Brushed Gold looks helped unify a remodel; regular wipe‑downs kept finishes looking fresh.
• Dual‑flush fans liked having a 0.8 gpf light flush for liquids when used consistently.